High Signal Podcasts Evidence ledger
Method
Browse
← All source episodes

Conversations with Tyler / episode intelligence

Scott Sumner on Monetary Rules, Blooming Late, and the Death of Cinema

8 Jan 2025 28 published claims 2 attributable people

Speakers in the public record

Claim mix

belief 15evaluation 7uncertainty 3commitment 1prediction 1preference 1

Evidence policy

Every row below preserves an exact excerpt. Identified speakers are linked; unresolved voices are labeled and excluded from people counts.

Claim ledger

The useful parts, with receipts.

28 published records

02 / belief

Let’s say we think of monetary policy as a game between the Fed and Congress, and Congress is always threatening to intervene in the economy, and most of those interventions are ill considered.

“Let’s say we think of monetary policy as a game between the Fed and Congress, and Congress is always threatening to intervene in the economy, and most of those interventions are ill considered.”
Speaker
Tyler Cowen
Publisher
Conversations with Tyler

07 / belief

My view is that cinema has evolved in a way where the more interesting directors today are ones that have sort of a more weird or edgy style, more unusual style, because the conventional masterpieces like The Godfather have already been done.

“My view is that cinema has evolved in a way where the more interesting directors today are ones that have sort of a more weird or edgy style, more unusual style, because the conventional masterpieces like The Godfather have already been done.”
Speaker
Scott Sumner
Publisher
Conversations with Tyler

08 / belief

I think that what happened in the case of COVID and other monetary policy mistakes, it’s more a question of the Fed just getting things wrong, misjudging the situation.

“I think that what happened in the case of COVID and other monetary policy mistakes, it’s more a question of the Fed just getting things wrong, misjudging the situation.”
Speaker
Scott Sumner
Publisher
Conversations with Tyler

09 / belief

I think my view would be, when you get a very bad recession, it’s typically the combination of negative nominal shocks and significant negative real shocks, often to credit markets.

“I think my view would be, when you get a very bad recession, it’s typically the combination of negative nominal shocks and significant negative real shocks, often to credit markets.”
Speaker
Tyler Cowen
Publisher
Conversations with Tyler

10 / belief

First of all, the deflation they’re going through, I would argue, is very similar to the deflation they went through in the late ’90s and early 2000s.

“First of all, the deflation they’re going through, I would argue, is very similar to the deflation they went through in the late ’90s and early 2000s.”
Speaker
Scott Sumner
Publisher
Conversations with Tyler

14 / belief

I think the directors coming along now are perhaps as talented as ever or more talented, but it’s my receptivity to what’s being done is maybe not as high as when I was younger.

“I think the directors coming along now are perhaps as talented as ever or more talented, but it’s my receptivity to what’s being done is maybe not as high as when I was younger.”
Speaker
Scott Sumner
Publisher
Conversations with Tyler

17 / belief

Also, in the field of economics, just seeing how policy shocks were interpreted at the time, as compared to how we think of them today — monetary policy decisions by Franklin Roosevelt and the New Deal and so on — I found that very enlightening.

“Also, in the field of economics, just seeing how policy shocks were interpreted at the time, as compared to how we think of them today — monetary policy decisions by Franklin Roosevelt and the New Deal and so on — I found that very enlightening.”
Speaker
Scott Sumner
Publisher
Conversations with Tyler

21 / evaluation

When there is a banking crisis that starts in one place and spreads, the initial crisis might have been due to mistakes made by that individual bank, but the spread across the financial system is usually because the policymakers allowed nominal GDP to fall sharply.

“When there is a banking crisis that starts in one place and spreads, the initial crisis might have been due to mistakes made by that individual bank, but the spread across the financial system is usually because the policymakers allowed nominal GDP to fall sharply.”
Speaker
Scott Sumner
Publisher
Conversations with Tyler

22 / evaluation

I think that, again and again, when you look at these cases where there’s some sort of monetary policy mistake — America in 1929, Argentina in the late 1990s — you see the monetary policy mistake occurring first, in an otherwise healthy economy; then you see the financial crisis developing as nominal GDP is falling sharply.

“I think that, again and again, when you look at these cases where there’s some sort of monetary policy mistake — America in 1929, Argentina in the late 1990s — you see the monetary policy mistake occurring first, in an otherwise healthy economy; then you see the financial crisis developing as nominal GDP is falling sharply.”
Speaker
Scott Sumner
Publisher
Conversations with Tyler

23 / evaluation

I think monetary policy is one area where mistakes actually do occur fairly often, and you get outcomes that governments actually don’t want because they’re not thinking about the situation in the correct way.

“I think monetary policy is one area where mistakes actually do occur fairly often, and you get outcomes that governments actually don’t want because they’re not thinking about the situation in the correct way.”
Speaker
Scott Sumner
Publisher
Conversations with Tyler

24 / evaluation

I think that colored the views of policymakers in the early 1930s, made them reluctant to move away from fiat until the pain was so intense that politics forced them off of gold standard to fiat money.

“I think that colored the views of policymakers in the early 1930s, made them reluctant to move away from fiat until the pain was so intense that politics forced them off of gold standard to fiat money.”
Speaker
Scott Sumner
Publisher
Conversations with Tyler

25 / prediction

I don’t know if there’ll be classics like It’s a Wonderful Life and that sort of classic, but I think films by Wes Anderson may hold up well because his style is so distinctive, his visual style especially.

“I don’t know if there’ll be classics like It’s a Wonderful Life and that sort of classic, but I think films by Wes Anderson may hold up well because his style is so distinctive, his visual style especially.”
Speaker
Scott Sumner
Publisher
Conversations with Tyler

27 / evaluation

Or there’s simply a cognitive error like you’re not thinking about the problem in the right way, which has also been an enormous problem in monetary economics because of confusion about what low interest rates mean and other things about monetary policy that confuse even policymakers, often, into thinking their policy stance is different from what it actually is.

“Or there’s simply a cognitive error like you’re not thinking about the problem in the right way, which has also been an enormous problem in monetary economics because of confusion about what low interest rates mean and other things about monetary policy that confuse even policymakers, often, into thinking their policy stance is different from what it actually is.”
Speaker
Scott Sumner
Publisher
Conversations with Tyler

28 / evaluation

When our instincts tell us that there’s something tautological about the correlation between real and nominal GDP in the United States, it’s because our instincts have recognized the fact that, in fact, most of the US business cycle is due to nominal shocks interacting with sticky wages.

“When our instincts tell us that there’s something tautological about the correlation between real and nominal GDP in the United States, it’s because our instincts have recognized the fact that, in fact, most of the US business cycle is due to nominal shocks interacting with sticky wages.”
Speaker
Scott Sumner
Publisher
Conversations with Tyler
Search evidence