High Signal Podcasts Evidence ledger
Method
Browse
← All source episodes

Conversations with Tyler / episode intelligence

Joseph Henrich on WEIRD Societies and Life Among Two Strange Tribes (Live at Mason)

14 Dec 2016 33 published claims 2 attributable people

Speakers in the public record

Claim mix

belief 18evaluation 7prediction 3uncertainty 2commitment 1observation 1preference 1

Evidence policy

Every row below preserves an exact excerpt. Identified speakers are linked; unresolved voices are labeled and excluded from people counts.

Claim ledger

The useful parts, with receipts.

33 published records

01 / belief

We got to talking over lunch and we realized in each of the areas for which we were experts on, that Westerners were unusual compared to all the other populations that had been studied.

“We got to talking over lunch and we realized in each of the areas for which we were experts on, that Westerners were unusual compared to all the other populations that had been studied.”
Speaker
Joseph Henrich
Publisher
Conversations with Tyler

04 / commitment

His current book, The Secret of Our Success, will be available for sale outside afterwards. We will move in just a second to question-and-answer.

“His current book, The Secret of Our Success, will be available for sale outside afterwards. We will move in just a second to question-and-answer.”
Speaker
Tyler Cowen
Publisher
Conversations with Tyler

05 / belief

One thing that’s interesting about the maverick question is we tend to think of the maverick as the individual learner, the person who comes up with their own idea, their own new idea. But my take on the history, at least of invention (that’s something I’ve spent a little bit of time on; it could be different in other domains), is great ideas actually come from a recombination.

“One thing that’s interesting about the maverick question is we tend to think of the maverick as the individual learner, the person who comes up with their own idea, their own new idea. But my take on the history, at least of invention (that’s something I’ve spent a little bit of time on; it could be different in other domains), is great ideas actually come from a recombination.”
Speaker
Joseph Henrich
Publisher
Conversations with Tyler

08 / uncertainty

Americans had — at least some of them — had relatively similar cultural backgrounds. I guess I don’t know enough about the data at the time to say.

“Americans had — at least some of them — had relatively similar cultural backgrounds. I guess I don’t know enough about the data at the time to say.”
Speaker
Joseph Henrich
Publisher
Conversations with Tyler

09 / belief

You mentioned how having one big god creates a bigger society while other smaller gods, I think you said, galvanizes cooperation in local communities.

“You mentioned how having one big god creates a bigger society while other smaller gods, I think you said, galvanizes cooperation in local communities.”
Speaker
Not verified from transcript
Publisher
Conversations with Tyler

11 / belief

Much of what I think we measure in behavioral economics, experimental economics is actually just a measurement of a culturally local social norm.

“Much of what I think we measure in behavioral economics, experimental economics is actually just a measurement of a culturally local social norm.”
Speaker
Joseph Henrich
Publisher
Conversations with Tyler

12 / observation

There’s lots of pieces to this puzzle. The key is to create interconnectedness. To explain the difference between Denmark and India: of course, Denmark is interconnected with many other populations, but the flow of information is much less constricted.

“There’s lots of pieces to this puzzle. The key is to create interconnectedness. To explain the difference between Denmark and India: of course, Denmark is interconnected with many other populations, but the flow of information is much less constricted.”
Speaker
Joseph Henrich
Publisher
Conversations with Tyler

13 / belief

I think the data is there. The question is why. One of the things I don’t think he takes into account sufficiently is that there could be long-run cultural differences between populations.

“I think the data is there. The question is why. One of the things I don’t think he takes into account sufficiently is that there could be long-run cultural differences between populations.”
Speaker
Joseph Henrich
Publisher
Conversations with Tyler

14 / belief

In my latest project I’m really looking at the kind of spread of the Western church into Europe and how it transformed the social structure in ways that I think led to individualism, it led to a different kind of cultural psychology that would eventually pave the way for secular institutions and economic growth.

“In my latest project I’m really looking at the kind of spread of the Western church into Europe and how it transformed the social structure in ways that I think led to individualism, it led to a different kind of cultural psychology that would eventually pave the way for secular institutions and economic growth.”
Speaker
Joseph Henrich
Publisher
Conversations with Tyler

16 / belief

I think the standard way from looking at religions all around the world is that most people accepted that their tribe or their clan or their group had a god and naturally that meant that other people’s tribes or groups had a god, so there were lots of gods and you dealt with your god and they had their god.

“I think the standard way from looking at religions all around the world is that most people accepted that their tribe or their clan or their group had a god and naturally that meant that other people’s tribes or groups had a god, so there were lots of gods and you dealt with your god and they had their god.”
Speaker
Joseph Henrich
Publisher
Conversations with Tyler

19 / belief

The importance of, say, our taste for sugar, our taste for fat seems to be a misfiring from our ancestral environments. But I think in the case of human cooperation that doesn’t fit the story.

“The importance of, say, our taste for sugar, our taste for fat seems to be a misfiring from our ancestral environments. But I think in the case of human cooperation that doesn’t fit the story.”
Speaker
Joseph Henrich
Publisher
Conversations with Tyler

20 / belief

I think when people use different languages, they can think about things in different ways and it’ll highlight different features of the problem.

“I think when people use different languages, they can think about things in different ways and it’ll highlight different features of the problem.”
Speaker
Joseph Henrich
Publisher
Conversations with Tyler

22 / evaluation

As you know, it’s a common 18th-century theme that the division of labor possibly will make us stupid or uninteresting. It seems that was wrong in the 18th century.

“As you know, it’s a common 18th-century theme that the division of labor possibly will make us stupid or uninteresting. It seems that was wrong in the 18th century.”
Speaker
Tyler Cowen
Publisher
Conversations with Tyler

23 / belief

You pass, OK. [laughter] Steven Pinker would not have passed, I think. [laughter] Maybe my pronunciation is wrong: Sawana, the village in the islands of Fiji.

“You pass, OK. [laughter] Steven Pinker would not have passed, I think. [laughter] Maybe my pronunciation is wrong: Sawana, the village in the islands of Fiji.”
Speaker
Tyler Cowen
Publisher
Conversations with Tyler

25 / prediction

When you get really low-status males, you might get a lot more risk-taking, steep temporal discounting, a psychological shift that gives you a chance to possibly climb the status hierarchy because you could determine, “I’m not going anywhere unless I do something big in order to get into that higher status.

“When you get really low-status males, you might get a lot more risk-taking, steep temporal discounting, a psychological shift that gives you a chance to possibly climb the status hierarchy because you could determine, “I’m not going anywhere unless I do something big in order to get into that higher status.”
Speaker
Joseph Henrich
Publisher
Conversations with Tyler

26 / evaluation

1. That’s because there’s a lot of variation in the environments that people in lower classes face compared to the relatively homogeneous environments that they face in upper classes.

“1. That’s because there’s a lot of variation in the environments that people in lower classes face compared to the relatively homogeneous environments that they face in upper classes.”
Speaker
Joseph Henrich
Publisher
Conversations with Tyler

27 / evaluation

We give our leaders too much respect because we used to need them to stop ourselves from being killed, whereas now we’re too loyal to the president.

“We give our leaders too much respect because we used to need them to stop ourselves from being killed, whereas now we’re too loyal to the president.”
Speaker
Tyler Cowen
Publisher
Conversations with Tyler

28 / prediction

I think the simplest and clearest one is this idea that I call the collective brain. This is simply the idea because we’re so dependent on learning from each other in order to do innovations and to construct increasingly fancy technologies, larger and more interconnected populations tend to have fancier tools and technologies.

“I think the simplest and clearest one is this idea that I call the collective brain. This is simply the idea because we’re so dependent on learning from each other in order to do innovations and to construct increasingly fancy technologies, larger and more interconnected populations tend to have fancier tools and technologies.”
Speaker
Joseph Henrich
Publisher
Conversations with Tyler

29 / evaluation

I think we don’t know from the numbers. I think if you look at all countries together, you can debate either side, whether countries as a whole are converging on the richest countries.

“I think we don’t know from the numbers. I think if you look at all countries together, you can debate either side, whether countries as a whole are converging on the richest countries.”
Speaker
Tyler Cowen
Publisher
Conversations with Tyler

30 / evaluation

When there’s not very much interesting things, interesting tools, techniques, ideas in the minds and behaviors of other members in your social group, individual learning is better because learning from others doesn’t get you anything because nobody else in the group has anything.

“When there’s not very much interesting things, interesting tools, techniques, ideas in the minds and behaviors of other members in your social group, individual learning is better because learning from others doesn’t get you anything because nobody else in the group has anything.”
Speaker
Joseph Henrich
Publisher
Conversations with Tyler

31 / evaluation

People would hide when they had a good crop and they brought in a big yield; they would underplay it and try to hide how much they did. They might have had a particularly good fertilizer, they might have figured out a new cropping technique — but that would be concealed from dissemination because of this concern that if people knew they were doing well they would envy them, and then bad stuff would happen to them.

“People would hide when they had a good crop and they brought in a big yield; they would underplay it and try to hide how much they did. They might have had a particularly good fertilizer, they might have figured out a new cropping technique — but that would be concealed from dissemination because of this concern that if people knew they were doing well they would envy them, and then bad stuff would happen to them.”
Speaker
Joseph Henrich
Publisher
Conversations with Tyler

32 / prediction

Just because things are going good for a little while — external forces can cause economies to grow and people could still have fundamentally zero-sum thinking or at least be able to drop back into it pretty quickly.

“Just because things are going good for a little while — external forces can cause economies to grow and people could still have fundamentally zero-sum thinking or at least be able to drop back into it pretty quickly.”
Speaker
Joseph Henrich
Publisher
Conversations with Tyler

33 / evaluation

If it was genetic, it wouldn’t go away in a few generations. It seems like they’re bringing heritage from the place, and it’s getting retransmitted because they’re in ethnic communities or they’re parents.

“If it was genetic, it wouldn’t go away in a few generations. It seems like they’re bringing heritage from the place, and it’s getting retransmitted because they’re in ethnic communities or they’re parents.”
Speaker
Joseph Henrich
Publisher
Conversations with Tyler
Search evidence