Public evidence record
Published podcast speaker
Claim ledger
29 transcript-backed records
01 / evaluation
“Those kind of grim mortality statistics, I think, are a huge difference psychologically between the ancient world and the modern.”
02 / belief
“You’re destroying other cultures and trying to warp or twist them into something, but what I think is interesting is that this vision he had of uniting cultures creates very problematic tensions among his own followers because the- Tensions among his own followers, because the Macedonians, his original troops, did not like this on the whole.”
03 / belief
“There’s a lot of central elements of what we think of as Roman civilization, which actually are borrowings, let’s say, from these older, slightly mysterious Etruscans.”
04 / belief
“I think of his as more kind of these punctuation points for just going along with what he’s saying.”
05 / belief
“On the other hand, he could be really hard-nosed and hard edged, and I think he was a very calculating person.”
06 / belief
“Otherwise, we’d all just be starting ground zero kind of just from the beginning. So our ability to store up knowledge and pass it on, I think is our special power as human beings.”
07 / belief
“I mean, no matter what the Romans did, they didn’t have that choice, that ability to think, “I can do something that will end life as we know it at least, on the planet,” and that’s a very different perspective. And I think weird and interesting moment right now, I mean, I’m getting way beyond ancient history here, but for a long time, we had this sort of stasis with the nuclear standoff, with mutually assured destruction between the US sort of block of nations and the Soviet ones, and it worked.”
08 / belief
“Now, before I go further with the story, and I think you probably know where it ends, I talk about how important your ancestors are in Roman culture.”
09 / uncertainty
“There was a revolution against her, and we don’t know what happened to her then, but she’s a really interesting figure.”
10 / belief
“The barbarians are so many different groups,. And weirdly, I think an important one that sometimes people tend to focus on the Huns and the Goths, the Vandals end up going to Spain, conquering Spain, and then crossing over into North Africa and kind of conquering North Africa as well.”
11 / belief
“I mean, if we adjust for that sort of factor, so that was a global war, I think that would be very familiar.”
12 / belief
“Eventually they get this typical sort of chain mail shirt, helmet shield, the classic sort of Roman legionary, I would say, is the one of the first and second centuries AD, so the early Roman Empire, and this is the guy who wore bands of steel arranged in sort of bands around their body.”
13 / uncertainty
“I mean, it was weirdly stable when it was a bipolar world where you had just sort of those two blocks. Now with a multipolar world with access to these weapons, I don’t know.”
14 / uncertainty
“I mean, that’s very similar in a way to our modern world wars where this was a global conflict, at least as they envisioned the world they knew of. And if we sort of, I don’t know, somehow factor for transportation time, I mean, I think you can argue that that was a bigger war than World War II.”
15 / belief
“I did a book on floods where I had to get really heavy into vectors of disease and hydraulics and engineering and all that stuff, and I think, again, having that sort of hard science combined with a humanist background, helps with those sorts of projects.”
16 / belief
“All this stuff that we think of today is, oh, very sophisticated techniques for propaganda and persuasion.”
17 / belief
“Sometimes geography is inevitability, and I think in the course of the wars between Rome and Carthage called the Punic Wars, there is this geographic inevitability to them.”
18 / belief
“On the other hand, to be fair, I mean there were Romans at the time who morally objected to them and said, “This is morally degenerate to take pleasure in this, and that’s wrong.” So I think in all eras, you have a diversity of opinions.”
19 / belief
“We investigated one possibility because we just had limited time and money and resources, but I think all these other things existed at the same time and we’re variants of it.”
20 / belief
“Is there a way to fix this?” And this is one of the few instances where the Romans, who I keep saying are very traditional and resist change, I think actually make a change and realize we got to do something different.”
21 / prediction
“I’m going to strike at the heart of this growing Roman Empire. And my hope is that if I can win a couple big battles against Rome in Italy, the Italians will want their freedom back and they’ll rebel from Rome and maybe even join me because most people who have been conquered want their freedom back, so this is a reasonable plan.”
22 / preference
“So we ended up using a kind of least common denominator glue. We used rabbit glue because it would’ve been available anywhere and it’s cheap.”
23 / recommendation
“I was really thinking if we were to write a realistic textbook of let’s say the Roman Empire, nine out of 10 chapters should be details of what it was like to be a small-time family farmer, because that’s what 90% of the people in the ancient world did.”
24 / evaluation
“Let’s not forget what life was like for 80, 90% of the people in the ancient world, the ones we don’t talk about, because that’s important too.”
25 / evaluation
“I think human nature is roughly constant. And for me, as an ancient historian, the kind of documents that I really like dealing with are not the traditional literary sources, but they’re the things that give us those little glimpse into everyday life.”
26 / prediction
“Because in my mind, the rise to dominance in a lot of the world of monotheistic religions is one of the huge turning points, because it’s just such a different mentality.”
27 / prediction
“Just to interrupt you, I hate wishy-washy answers, which is what I kind of said. So I will give you this, I think by the end of the 5th century AD, the Western Roman Empire has transformed into something different.”
28 / evaluation
“Now, stepping back from this in a broad way, I think you can say that Christianity really was different in some ways, and had some things that maybe the Romans should rightfully have viewed as a threat.”
29 / evaluation
“It’s wrong for you to beat me because I am a citizen and that gives me certain protections. So that notion of citizenship is something that I think, the Romans really emphasize and becomes a legacy to a lot of civilizations today, where citizenship means something.”