High Signal Podcasts Evidence ledger
Method
Browse
← Back to evidence

Evidence receipt / uncertainty

Published · transcript-backed

Nikhila Ravi: uncertainty

7 Aug 2024 Latent Space Segment Anything 2: Demo-first Model Development

“People in the community help us address, but one definitely challenging case is where there are multiple similar looking objects, especially if that's like a crowded scene with multiple similar looking objects, keeping track of the target object is a challenge. That's still something that I don't know if we've solved perfectly, but again, the ability to provide refinement clicks.”

— Nikhila Ravi

Source trail

Everything needed to verify it.

Speaker
Nikhila Ravi
Attribution
Verified speaker
Claim type
uncertainty
Recorded
7 Aug 2024
Publisher
Latent Space

Transcript context

…I think so. If one wanted to be really precise with how literature refers to object re identification, object re identification is not only what SAM does for identifying that an object is similar across frames, It's also assigning a unique ID. How do you think about models keeping track of occurrences of objects in addition to seeing that the same looking thing is present in multiple places? Yeah, it's a good question. I think, you know, SAM2 definitely isn't perfect and there's many limitations that, you know, we'd love to see. People in the community help us address, but one definitely challenging case is where there are multiple similar looking objects, especially if that's like a crowded scene with multiple similar looking objects, keeping track of the target object is a challenge. That's still something that I don't know if we've solved perfectly, but again, the ability to provide refinement clicks. That's one way to sort of circumvent that problem. In most cases, when there's lots of similar looking objects, if you add enough refinement clicks, you can get the perfect track throughout the video. So definitely that's one way to, to solve that problem. You know, we could have better motion estimation. We could do other things in the model to be able to disambiguate similar looking objects more effectively. I'm just interested in leaving breadcrumbs for other researchers, anyone interested in this kind of architecture. Like, are there papers that you would refer people to that are influential in your thinking or, you know, have, have other interesting alternative approaches?…

Stored transcript either side of the excerpt. The highlighted words are the published quote; the surrounding text is unedited source, never generated.

Search evidence