Scott Alexander: belief

Transcript context

…But he’s a smart guy. So I think that the aggregate opinion has been underestimating the pace of both technical progress and deployment. I agree that there have been plenty of people who’ve been more bullish than me and have been already proven wrong, but they’re not me. Wait a second. We don’t have to guess about aggregate opinion, we can look at Metaculus. Metaculus, I think their timeline was like 2050 back in 2020. It gradually went down to like 2040 two or three years ago. Now it’s at 2030, so it’s barely ahead of us. Again, that may turn out to be wrong, but it does look like the Metaculans overall have, have been too pessimistic, thinking too long term rather than too optimistic. And I think that’s like the closest thing we have to a neutral aggregator where we’re not cherry picking things. Yeah. I had this interesting experience yesterday. We were having lunch with this senior AI researcher, probably makes on the order of millions a month or something, and we were asking him, “how much are the AIs helping you?” And he said, “in domains which I understand well, and it’s closer to autocomplete but more intense, there it’s maybe saving me four to eight hours a week.” But then he says, “in domains which I’m less familiar with, if I need to go wrangle up some hardware library or make some modification to the kernel or whatever, where I know less, that saves me on the order of 24 hours a week.” Now, with current models. What I found really surprising is that the help is bigger where it’s less like autocomplete and more like a novel contribution. It’s like a more significant productivity improvement there.…

Stored transcript either side of the excerpt. The highlighted words are the published quote; the surrounding text is unedited source, never generated.