High Signal Podcasts Evidence ledger
Method
Browse
← Back to evidence

Evidence receipt / evaluation

Published · transcript-backed

Francois Chollet: evaluation

11 Jun 2024 Dwarkesh Podcast Francois Chollet — Why the biggest AI models can't solve simple puzzles

“You can apply it to more and more tasks. But general intelligence is not task-specific skill scaled up to many skills, because there is an infinite space of possible skills.”

— Francois Chollet

Source trail

Everything needed to verify it.

Speaker
Francois Chollet
Attribution
Verified speaker
Claim type
evaluation
Recorded
11 Jun 2024
Publisher
Dwarkesh Podcast

Transcript context

…But then isn't that intelligence? No, it's not. If you scale up your database and keep adding more knowledge and program templates to it, then sure it becomes more and more skillful. You can apply it to more and more tasks. But general intelligence is not task-specific skill scaled up to many skills, because there is an infinite space of possible skills. General intelligence is the ability to approach any problem, any skill, and very quickly master it using very little data. This is what makes you able to face anything you might ever encounter. This is the definition of generality. Generality is not specificity scaled up. It is the ability to apply your mind to anything at all, to arbitrary things. This fundamentally requires the ability to adapt, to learn on the fly efficiently. My claim is that by doing pre-training on bigger and bigger models, you are gaining that capacity to generalize very efficiently. Let me give you an example. Your own company Google, in their paper on Gemini 1.5, had this very interesting example. They would give the model, in context, the grammar book and the dictionary of a language that has fewer than 200 living speakers. It's not in the pre-training data. You just give it the dictionary and it basically is able to speak this language and translate to it, including the complex and organic ways in which languages are structured. If you showed me a dictionary from English to Spanish, I'm not going to be able to pick up how to structure sentences and how to say things in Spanish. Because of the representations that it has gained through this pre-training, it is able to now learn a new language extremely efficiently. Doesn't that show that this kind of pre-training actually does increase your ability to learn new tasks?…

Stored transcript either side of the excerpt. The highlighted words are the published quote; the surrounding text is unedited source, never generated.

Search evidence