High Signal Podcasts Evidence ledger
Method
Browse
← Back to evidence

Evidence receipt / belief

Published · transcript-backed

Cass Sunstein: belief

22 Jun 2016 Conversations with Tyler Cass Sunstein on Judicial Minimalism, the Supreme Court, and Star Wars (Live at Mason)

“Now, it is true that the heroin ban does not eliminate heroin, and it has ancillary consequences that aren’t good. But I would say with respect to some product — let’s say it’s a food where there’s a 1/x chance of death from consuming it, and x is not that high a number — to say to people, you know, “You can have this.”

— Cass Sunstein

Source trail

Everything needed to verify it.

Speaker
Cass Sunstein
Attribution
Verified speaker
Claim type
belief
Recorded
22 Jun 2016
Publisher
Conversations with Tyler

Transcript context

…Sure. To nudge people and not to take the step we’ve now taken might leave, you know, a lot of tragedy around. Now, it is true that the heroin ban does not eliminate heroin, and it has ancillary consequences that aren’t good. But I would say with respect to some product — let’s say it’s a food where there’s a 1/x chance of death from consuming it, and x is not that high a number — to say to people, you know, “You can have this. Note that your death risk is 1/x.” Why is it so great to shift from banning the thing to allowing people to have it when you’re going to see a lot of bodies on the streets? Say I’m dying of a terminal disease, and there’s a treatment. It probably won’t help me, but there’s a one-tenth of one percent chance that it will. And I want to use it — it’s kind of a self-defense argument. And I say, “Well, self-defense — that’s like a minimal value we all would agree upon.” I love nudge. Let’s take the FDA out of the picture and just put it in the Banned Products Store and have big huge signs, bad music surrounding it — disco, whatever we need to do — telling that it’s not any good, but let me buy it. So, I want more nudge than you do.…

Stored transcript either side of the excerpt. The highlighted words are the published quote; the surrounding text is unedited source, never generated.

Search evidence